20 Underrated Movies From Legendary Filmmakers
By Sophia Maddox | March 11, 2024
Damien Chazelle: Babylon
Embark on a journey into the lesser-known realms of cinema, where hidden treasures await discovery. Within the vast archives of legendary filmmakers lie forgotten masterpieces that deserve a second glance. From the enigmatic twists of David Lynch's "Lost Highway" to the heartfelt nostalgia of Tim Burton's "Ed Wood," these films defy conventions and offer unique insights into the creative genius of their creators. Amidst the shadows of their more celebrated works, these underrated gems beckon audiences to explore uncharted territories of emotion, imagination, and storytelling. Join us as we shine a light on 20 cinematic treasures that may have slipped under your radar.
Set in the golden age of Hollywood during the transition from silent films to talkies, "Babylon" explores the industry's seismic shifts and the lives caught in its whirlwind. While the movie was largely ignored by mainstream audiences, "Babylon" stands out for its ambitious storytelling and Chazelle's distinctive directorial style. Loosely based on some of Hollywood's movie icons, the story depicts ambition at any cost, all within the excesses of Hollywood.
Chazelle, known for his captivating narratives and dynamic visuals in films like "Whiplash" and "La La Land," infuses "Babylon" with his trademark cinematic flair. The movie's exploration of Hollywood's transformative era promises to offer a fresh perspective on familiar themes of ambition, love, and the pursuit of artistic excellence. Despite the buzz surrounding its production and cast, "Babylon" faced the challenge of living up to the expectations set by Chazelle's previous works.
Martin Scorsese: After Hours
"After Hours" stands as one of Martin Scorsese's underrated gems amidst his illustrious career. Released in 1985, the film diverges from Scorsese's signature gangster narratives, delving into the surreal and comedic realms of New York City's nightlife. Set over one chaotic night, the plot follows Paul Hackett (portrayed by Griffin Dunne), whose innocent quest for excitement spirals into a series of absurd misadventures.
Scorsese's direction in "After Hours" showcases his mastery in creating tension and unpredictability within the confines of a single night. The film's kinetic energy mirrors the pulsating rhythm of the city that never sleeps, amplified by its eccentric characters and bizarre situations. Despite its departure from Scorsese's typical themes, "After Hours" retains his trademark visual flair and meticulous attention to detail.
The film's underrated status comes from its initial reception, as the film struggled to find a mainstream audience upon release. However, over time, its cult following has grown, with audiences appreciating its dark humor and surreal narrative.
Wes Anderson: The Darjeeling Limited
"The Darjeeling Limited" offers a whimsical journey through the picturesque landscapes of India, punctuated by Anderson's trademark visual style and quirky characters.
Centered around three estranged brothers, played by Owen Wilson, Adrien Brody, and Jason Schwartzman, "The Darjeeling Limited" follows their tumultuous train voyage across India as they attempt to reconnect and reconcile their fractured relationships. Anderson's direction infuses the film with vibrant colors, meticulously composed shots, and a melancholic yet comedic tone that encapsulates the complexities of familial dynamics and the quest for emotional healing.
Despite its stellar ensemble cast and Anderson's unique directorial vision, "The Darjeeling Limited" received mixed reviews upon its release and failed to achieve the same level of commercial success as some of Anderson's other works, like "The Grand Budapest Hotel" or "Moonrise Kingdom." However, its nuanced exploration of themes such as grief, forgiveness, and cultural immersion make it a poignant and underrated entry in Anderson's filmography. The film was released in 2007.
Sam Raimi: The Quick and the Dead
Released in 1995, this Western thriller offers a unique twist on the genre, blending elements of classic Westerns with Raimi's trademark style of kinetic action and dark humor.
The film follows the story of a mysterious gunslinger, played by Sharon Stone, who enters the town of Redemption to seek vengeance in a deadly quick-draw tournament orchestrated by the ruthless outlaw Herod, portrayed by Gene Hackman. With a stellar ensemble cast including Russell Crowe, Leonardo DiCaprio, and Lance Henriksen, "The Quick and the Dead" boasts compelling performances that bring its eclectic characters to life.
Raimi's direction infuses the film with dynamic camerawork, stylized visuals, and a palpable sense of tension that keeps viewers on the edge of their seats throughout. Despite receiving mixed reviews upon its initial release, "The Quick and the Dead" has gained a cult following over the years, with audiences appreciating its inventive approach to the Western genre and its homage to spaghetti Westerns of the past.
Tim Burton: Ed Wood
Buena Vista Pictures Distribution
"Ed Wood," a masterpiece by Tim Burton, often stands overlooked amid the filmmaker's more prominent works. Released in 1994, the film serves as a loving homage to the titular filmmaker, widely regarded as one of the worst directors in cinema history. Johnny Depp delivers a captivating performance as Ed Wood, portraying his infectious enthusiasm and unwavering dedication to filmmaking despite countless setbacks.
Burton's direction infuses "Ed Wood" with a blend of whimsy and melancholy, capturing the eccentricities of its characters and the peculiar charm of the B-movie industry. The film delves into Wood's unorthodox methods and his unconventional collaborations with an eclectic group of actors and crew members, including the iconic Bela Lugosi, played by Martin Landau in an Academy Award-winning performance.
Despite its critical acclaim and cult following, "Ed Wood" did not achieve the same commercial success as Burton's more mainstream projects like "Batman" or "Edward Scissorhands." However, its celebration of the indomitable spirit of independent filmmaking makes it a hidden gem within Burton's filmography.
Paul Thomas Anderson: Punch Drunk Love
Released in 2002, the film is a departure from Anderson's sprawling ensemble dramas, offering a more intimate and idiosyncratic exploration of love, anxiety, and redemption.
Starring Adam Sandler in a revelatory performance as Barry Egan, a socially awkward small-business owner prone to fits of rage, "Punch-Drunk Love" subverts expectations with its unconventional narrative and visual style. Anderson's direction gives the film a sense of surrealism, using vibrant colors, dynamic camera movements, and a mesmerizing score by Jon Brion to evoke the inner turmoil and yearning of its protagonist.
Despite receiving positive reviews from critics, "Punch-Drunk Love" remains relatively overlooked in comparison to Anderson's other works like "Boogie Nights" and "There Will Be Blood." However, its impact on independent cinema and its cult following have grown over time, with audiences appreciating its emotional depth and Sandler's nuanced portrayal of a complex character.
Francis Ford Coppola: Rumble Fish
Released in 1983, this visually striking adaptation of S.E. Hinton's novel offers a stylized and introspective exploration of youth, identity, and disillusionment in a decaying industrial town.
Set in a gritty, urban landscape, "Rumble Fish" follows the tumultuous relationship between Rusty James, played by Matt Dillon, and his older brother, the Motorcycle Boy, portrayed by Mickey Rourke. Coppola's direction infuses the film with dreamlike imagery, experimental cinematography, and a haunting score by Stewart Copeland, elevating it beyond typical coming-of-age narratives.
Despite its innovative approach and stellar cast, including Diane Lane and Dennis Hopper, "Rumble Fish" received mixed reviews upon its release and struggled to find an audience. However, its influence on independent cinema and its cult following have grown over time, with audiences appreciating its unconventional narrative structure and visual storytelling.
"Rumble Fish" remains a testament to Coppola's versatility as a filmmaker, showcasing his willingness to take creative risks and push the boundaries of cinematic storytelling.
Sofia Coppola: Somewhere
Released in 2010, "Somewhere" takes a contemplative dive into the life of a disillusioned Hollywood actor named Johnny Marco, played by Stephen Dorff, and his unexpected bond with his young daughter, Cleo, portrayed by Elle Fanning. Set against the backdrop of the Chateau Marmont hotel in Los Angeles, Coppola crafts a minimalist yet introspective narrative that explores themes of celebrity, existential ennui, and the search for meaning amid fame and fortune.
Coppola's direction in "Somewhere" is marked by her trademark aesthetic sensibility and attention to emotional subtlety. Through lingering shots and quiet moments, she invites viewers into the inner world of her characters, allowing for a deeply immersive cinematic experience. The film's deliberate pacing and understated storytelling may have contributed to its underappreciated status, as it eschews conventional plot-driven narratives in favor of character-driven introspection.
Despite receiving mixed reviews upon its release, "Somewhere" resonates with those who appreciate its meditative tone and poignant exploration of human connection. As with many of Coppola's works, its true beauty lies in its understated elegance and ability to evoke complex emotions with seemingly simple scenes.
David Fincher: Panic Room
Released in 2002, "Panic Room" follows a mother and daughter, played by Jodie Foster and Kristen Stewart, who find themselves trapped in their home's panic room by burglars on the hunt for hidden riches. What unfolds is a pulse-pounding cat-and-mouse game within the confines of a seemingly impenetrable safe space.
Fincher's meticulous attention to detail and innovative camera work elevate "Panic Room" beyond typical home invasion thrillers. From the claustrophobic confines of the panic room to the sprawling yet sinister mansion, every inch of the setting is imbued with a sense of menace and unease. The film's taut pacing and escalating stakes keep viewers on the edge of their seats throughout.
Despite receiving generally positive reviews upon release, "Panic Room" often gets overshadowed by Fincher's more celebrated works such as "Fight Club" and "Se7en." However, its expertly crafted suspense and compelling performances make it a standout entry in Fincher's filmography.
Stanley Kubrick: Barry Lyndon
"Barry Lyndon," directed by Stanley Kubrick, is an underrated masterpiece that often remains overshadowed by the director's more celebrated works like "2001: A Space Odyssey" and "The Shining." Released in 1975, the film is an adaptation of William Makepeace Thackeray's novel and follows the life of Redmond Barry, an Irish rogue who rises from poverty to wealth and status in 18th-century Europe.
Kubrick's meticulous attention to detail is evident throughout "Barry Lyndon," from its breathtaking cinematography to its sumptuous period costumes and meticulously recreated settings. The film's deliberate pacing and languid storytelling may have contributed to its initial underappreciation, but closer examination reveals Kubrick's unparalleled craftsmanship and thematic depth.
"Barry Lyndon" is a visual feast, with each frame resembling a classical painting or photo come to life - a nod to Kubrick's past life as an accomplished photographer. Kubrick's use of natural light and carefully composed shots evoke the grandeur and elegance of the era while also exploring timeless themes of ambition, power, and the human condition.
Robert Altman: Popeye
Released in 1980, this live-action adaptation of the beloved comic strip and cartoon character brings the colorful world of Popeye and the residents of Sweethaven to life in a whimsical and quirky fashion.
Altman's direction imbues "Popeye" with a distinct charm and offbeat sensibility, capturing the spirit of E.C. Segar's original creations while infusing the story with his own creative flair. The film boasts a stellar cast led by Robin Williams in his feature film debut as the titular sailor, Popeye, and Shelley Duvall as the spirited Olive Oyl. Their performances, along with the supporting cast, bring depth and humor to the eccentric characters populating Sweethaven.
Despite its ambitious production design and faithful re-creation of the comic strip's aesthetic, "Popeye" received mixed reviews upon its release and didn't find mainstream success. However, the film has garnered a cult following over the years, with audiences appreciating its whimsical atmosphere, catchy musical numbers, and Williams' endearing portrayal of the iconic character.
Michael Mann: Thief
Released in 1981, this gritty crime drama showcases Mann's signature style and thematic depth, laying the groundwork for his later masterpieces like "Heat" and "Collateral."
"Thief" follows the story of Frank, played by James Caan, who seeks to break free from a life of crime and build a future with his newfound love. Mann's direction immerses viewers in the seedy underworld of Chicago, capturing the city's neon-lit streets and shadowy alleyways with atmospheric precision.
The film's intense action sequences, coupled with its nuanced exploration of loyalty, betrayal, and the pursuit of the American Dream, set it apart from conventional crime thrillers. James Caan delivers a powerhouse performance as Frank, bringing vulnerability and raw emotion to the character.
Despite receiving critical acclaim upon its release, "Thief" remains relatively underseen compared to Mann's more commercially successful ventures. However, its influence on the crime genre and its enduring relevance as a character-driven thriller have earned it a dedicated following among cinephiles.
Spike Lee: Clockers
Released in 1995, "Clockers" is an adaptation of Richard Price's novel and delves into the gritty realities of life in the projects of Brooklyn, New York. Set against the backdrop of inner-city struggles and urban decay, "Clockers" presents a compelling narrative that explores themes of crime, poverty, and the complexities of morality.
Lee's direction in "Clockers" is marked by his trademark visual style and keen social commentary. The film's ensemble cast, including Harvey Keitel, John Turturro, and Mekhi Phifer, deliver powerful performances that breathe life into the characters and their respective struggles.
Despite receiving critical acclaim for its authentic portrayal of urban life and thought-provoking themes, "Clockers" did not achieve the same level of commercial success as some of Lee's other works. However, its impact on cinema and its enduring relevance as a social commentary remain undeniable.
Christopher Nolan: Insomnia
"Insomnia" often stands in the shadow of Nolan's more blockbuster hits, like "Inception" and "The Dark Knight Trilogy." Released in 2002, "Insomnia" is a psychological thriller that showcases Nolan's talent for crafting complex narratives and exploring the darker recesses of the human psyche.
Starring Al Pacino as a troubled detective sent to investigate a murder in a small Alaskan town, alongside Robin Williams as the enigmatic suspect, "Insomnia" delves into themes of guilt, obsession, and moral ambiguity. There's a palpable sense of tension and unease, enhanced by the stark, desolate backdrop of the Alaskan wilderness.
Despite receiving positive reviews from critics, "Insomnia" often gets overlooked in discussions of Nolan's filmography. However, its intricate plot, compelling performances, and atmospheric cinematography make it a solid entry in the psychological thriller genre.
Quentin Tarantino: Death Proof
Released in 2007 as part of the double-feature "Grindhouse" project alongside Robert Rodriguez's "Planet Terror," "Death Proof" pays homage to the exploitation films of the 1970s.
The film follows a group of women who become the targets of a psychotic stuntman, portrayed by Kurt Russell, with a deadly "death-proof" car. Tarantino's direction in "Death Proof" is characterized by its sharp and witty dialogue, expertly crafted suspense, and exhilarating car chase sequences that pay homage to classic grindhouse cinema.
Despite its innovative approach and standout performances, "Death Proof" did not receive the same level of commercial success or critical acclaim as Tarantino's other works like "Pulp Fiction" or "Inglourious Basterds." However, its cult following has grown over the years, with audiences appreciating its subversive take on the exploitation genre and its empowered female characters.
Alfred Hitchcock: Rope
Released in 1948, the film stands out as one of Hitchcock's most daring and innovative works, employing a unique storytelling technique and exploring themes of morality and guilt.
Set in real-time, "Rope" follows two friends who commit a murder as an intellectual exercise to prove their superiority. They then host a dinner party, with the victim's body hidden in plain sight. Hitchcock's direction in "Rope" is characterized by its use of long takes, creating the illusion of a single continuous shot and heightening the tension and suspense as the evening unfolds.
Despite its technical achievements and Hitchcock's masterful direction, "Rope" received mixed reviews upon its release and did not achieve the same level of commercial success as some of Hitchcock's other works, like "Psycho." However, its bold experimentation with form and its exploration of dark psychological themes have earned it a dedicated following among cinephiles.
The Wachowskis: Speed Racer
Released in 2008, "Speed Racer" offers a vibrant and exhilarating homage to the beloved anime series of the same name, blending stunning visuals, innovative storytelling, and heartfelt themes of family and perseverance.
The Wachowskis' direction in "Speed Racer" is marked by their trademark visual style and boundary-pushing special effects. The film's hyper-stylized cinematography, kaleidoscopic color palette, and exhilarating racing sequences create a sensory experience unlike any other. While some critics dismissed it as style over substance, closer examination reveals deeper layers of narrative complexity and emotional resonance.
Despite its innovative approach and dedicated fanbase, "Speed Racer" struggled to find mainstream success upon its release. However, its reputation has grown over time, with audiences appreciating its bold vision and imaginative storytelling. "Speed Racer" stands as a testament to the Wachowskis' creative ingenuity and their ability to transcend genre conventions.
John Carpenter: In the Mouth of Madness
Released in 1994, the film is a chilling exploration of psychological horror and existential dread, drawing inspiration from the works of H.P. Lovecraft and the concept of cosmic horror.
Carpenter's direction in "In the Mouth of Madness" is marked by its atmospheric tension, surreal imagery, and mind-bending narrative twists. The film follows an insurance investigator, played by Sam Neill, as he delves into the mysterious disappearance of a horror novelist whose works seem to be driving readers insane.
Despite its compelling premise and Carpenter's skillful execution, "In the Mouth of Madness" received mixed reviews upon its release and didn't find an audience. However, its reputation has grown over time, with cinephiles appreciating its intricate plot, eerie atmosphere, and thought-provoking themes.
David Lynch: Lost Highway
Released in 1997, "Lost Highway" is a mind-bending journey through the dark recesses of the subconscious, blurring the lines between reality and illusion.
Lynch's direction in "Lost Highway" is marked by its dreamlike atmosphere, haunting imagery, and nonlinear narrative structure. The film follows a jazz musician, played by Bill Pullman, who becomes embroiled in a nightmarish descent into madness and identity crisis after receiving a mysterious videotape of his own home.
Despite its immersive storytelling and Lynch's trademark surrealism, "Lost Highway" received mixed reviews upon its release. However, its reputation has grown over time, with cinephiles appreciating its labyrinthine plot, atmospheric cinematography, and haunting score by Angelo Badalamenti. "Lost Highway" stands as a testament to Lynch's unparalleled ability to tap into the subconscious and explore the darker aspects of human nature.
Joel and Ethan Coen: The Man Who Wasn't There
Released in 2001, "The Man Who Wasn't There" is a neo-noir masterpiece that quietly simmers with existential angst, dark humor, and meticulous visual style.
Set in a post-World War II California town, "The Man Who Wasn't There" follows the story of Ed Crane, a laconic barber played by Billy Bob Thornton, whose life takes a dark turn after he becomes embroiled in a blackmail scheme. The Coen Brothers' direction in the film is marked by their signature blend of deadpan humor, atmospheric cinematography, and intricate storytelling.
Despite its stellar cast, which includes Frances McDormand, James Gandolfini, and Scarlett Johansson, "The Man Who Wasn't There" received relatively little attention upon its release and often gets overshadowed by the Coen Brothers' more widely recognized films like "Fargo" and "No Country for Old Men." However, its subtle brilliance and masterful craftsmanship have earned it a dedicated following among cinephiles.
